***The Commercialism of the Christ
Okay, okay, I know I’m sounding harsh here, but there ya go.
Everywhere I go I see things I can buy, now that Mel’s movie has made such a big splash. I see huge banners up at churches (or I did right before Easter) saying that I should attend that church to better understand The Passion of the Christ. I see the soundtrack everywhere. (I have a question for those who’ve seen the movie and now buy the soundtrack: do you see the torture as you listen? When my kids buy soundtracks they often describe what is going on while the music plays.) You can buy a poster. Cups. Jewelry. “Witness tools”. Plaques with the actor hanging on the cross. Keyrings. Zipper pulls. Books.
The movie itself has made more money than I can even imagine.
I know a lot of people aren’t bothered by all of this. I am.
What can I say?
Now some Christians I know are saying that the Passion is simply a great witness tool, and that it’s great to “reach people for Christ” and I wonder … was this the problem for the past couple thousand years? Was God just powerless before this violent movie? And of course you know what I think. (I’m so transparent, aren’t I?)
I’m sorry if I’m offending some folks here. (My two readers?!) But I’m so weary of Christian Commercialism. I can’t even go into Berean bookstore anymore. When I get the ads for CBD (Christian Book Distributors) I toss it before I toss something else. (Like my cookies. Get it? That was clever. Or not.)
I wonder if Jesus would like to toss some of the junk and perhaps turn over some tables.
***Other Hesitant Christians
But I’m not alone (I keep repeating this to myself over and over). I was pleased to read that others are concerned about what this movie “means”. This thoughtful article doesn’t dismiss the movie, but it does express concerns that I believe are valid.
And then there’s this:
As I observed the reactions of Christians to the film, be it in the press or around me, my reactions ran the gamut from apathetic to amused (I find it somewhat ironic that, while Christians denounce violence in movies as a general rule, they’re practically using this film’s violence as a selling point), from skeptical to annoyed.
This is the new “safe” movie for Christians to enjoy, to trumpet, to claim as our own. I’m not sure what the last one was, maybe “The Omega Code” or “Jonah: A VeggieTales Movie”, but “The Passion” is the “safe” movie for 2004. And the Church will flock to it in droves, watch it, feel affirmed, and completely ignore the other movies (not to mention CDs, books, etc.) that have been released with powerful and valid stories – stories that need to be discerned, discussed, and affirmed. (Jeffrey Overstreet, one of my favorite critics, discusses this in this beautifully-worded letter.)
But we don’t have time for them. We’ve got “The Passion”, along with little cottage industry that has sprung up around it, with inspirational books, CDs, and jewelry. And from this stronghold, we can reach out to the heathen, liberal masses around us and make them realize their need for Christ.
But contrary to what Christians seem to be saying, I’m somewhat skeptical that this will be a great outreach tool, at least directly. While it’s certain to increase people’s curiosity and open avenues that way, Gibson is preaching to the choir with this movie – which makes sense when you realize that he made this movie as a personal statement. The movie assumes that you know an awful lot about Christ to begin with – a few flashbacks aside, you’re not given much backstory or history of Christ and His ministry. The film feels more like a snapshot of one specific instant in history, but with little context provided for the non-Christian moviegoer.
For example, the violence in this film has little deeper meaning unless you have some knowledge of the real, theological need for Christ’s atonement and sacrifice. If you do, then great – this film could very well inspire and move you. But if you don’t, then this film will either disgust you – or you’ll have found the first great Bible splatter film (“The Jesus Chainsaw Massacre”, as it were).
Click here to read the complete article.
And I still won’t see the movie. I won’t see Kill Bill either. Or The Deer Hunter. Or The Texas Chainsaw Massacre. I don’t pay to see violence. Period.
—–